I know we've always played on All Madden, but currently there is a game breaking bug that only occurs on All Madden.  It's not something a player has to TRY to do, so it'll happen and WILL change the outcome of games.  I have tested this out myself and replicated it all 4 times that I tried.  It's a qb option that the defender just watches the QB run by him.  It happens with multiple different plays.  I did this with Matt Ryan and got a consistent 8-12 yards.  Imagine a mobile QB.

I've been catching a lot of shit lately for it being on All Pro.  I'll tell you now that if it wasn't for this bug we'd be on All Madden.  That being said, I don't see a difference user VS user playing on All Pro.  ONE person has came to me with complaints that his DBs dont "react" to the ball correctly.  I played a head to head All Pro game with this person so they could show me what they're talking about.  Both of our DBs reacted correctly in every situation they were close enough for.  There wasn't a single fucked up play.  In fact, he picked me off 3x and I picked him of 1x.  I understand the DBs are dropping balls thrown right to them.  That's life and it happens on All Madden too.  There are multiple topics on this dropped interception thing and it's not going to get fixed by switching to All Madden. 

The average person in this league probably throws 10 bad passes a game.  Anything over 4 TOTAL picks per game isn''t realistic anyway, unless that player is the worst Madden passer ever.

There are no blowout games, all but 1 game was pretty close in week 1.  So unless someone can give me a LEGITIMATE reason to switch, I'm not going to risk having games fucked up over a glitch.  Personally, I don't even see a difference between the two levels versus a USER. 

Anyone who decides they want to do some testing to try and make a case....  Make sure it's online and versus a USER.  The game plays completely different versus CPU.

also..I would much rather (along with others who I've talked with) adjust sliders from here than go right to all madden

Before I go over my thoughts, I do feel that our league could adjust to all pro or all madden. Neither setting is broken, it's just a question of what's better.

We all were under the assumption we would be using all-madden settings prior to beginning the CFM. A bunch of us played practice games- I was surprised at the regularity with which safeties and CBs could predict routes- they'd abandon their assignments to go after other receivers if nobody entered their zones. They seemed to play extremely fast.

On all-pro, it seems that quarterbacks are far more accurate. It seemed like only elite quarterbacks were able to fit the ball into tight windows on all madden, but any Joe Schmo can on all pro.

I don't necessarily agree with the rationale that which she stay on all pro because of a handful of glitched plays- but I do prefer all-pro slightly. I think it would be easier to tune down QB accuracy than it would be to lower the effectiveness of secondaries.

All Pro and change sliders around... that's my opinion. All Madden is like watching instant transmission by any player on defense. Suddenly they can jump 20 yards in a leap and get the INT. I hated it. Made me hate the game. We can play with sliders.

I just wish it was easier to run but I am happy to see sub 5.0 YPC.

Lower QB accuracy by a lot and you don't have to move a thing. It's QB accuracy that is the problem. I shouldn't feel like Prime Peyton Manning with Joe Flacco.